It’s hard to choose what to focus on while reading Catching Fire. So much is happening in such few pages. Should you focus on the budding rebellion? The complicated love story? The details of day-to-day survival? It’s hard to decide.
In a way, that makes this book that much better to reread. Each time you read it, you find yourself catching new details and analyzing new things. During these chapters, I was newly surprised by something as simple as what plays on tv. Do they really have so few options?
That really makes me wonder what people in the Capitol do to pass their time. I always thought of them as an entertainment district so to speak. They make clothes and hairstyles. They throw parties. I kind of thought they made television shows as well. Apparently not though.
Back of the Book (Amazon.com)
Against all odds, Katniss Everdeen has won the annual Hunger Games with fellow district tribute Peeta Mellark. But it was a victory won by defiance of the Capitol and their harsh rules. Katniss and Peeta should be happy. After all, they have just won for themselves and their families a life of safety and plenty. But there are rumors of rebellion among the subjects, and Katniss and Peeta, to their horror, are the faces of that rebellion. The Capitol is angry. The Capitol wants revenge.
Disclaimer: My Chapter Thoughts DO INCLUDE SPOILERS. They assume that you have read ALL of The Hunger Games series (books 1-3). They will mostly contain spoilers, however, in the chapter that they are covering.
Chapter Ten Thoughts
When Katniss enters the forest at the end of the previous chapter, she encounters a woman dressed in a white Peacekeeper uniform. The woman is out of place. She stands out against the backdrop of forest ground. When Katniss aims her bow at the woman, the woman shows her a cracker with Katniss’s mockingjay stamped inside the center of it. At the beginning of chapter ten, the unknown woman explains that the stamp means she is on Katniss’s side.
She, and a young girl who emerges from a cabin in the forest, explains that they’re on their way to District 13, the district that was supposedly destroyed in the rebellion that caused the Hunger Games to be created in punishment. They tell Katniss that they believe District 13 still exists because the Capitol replays the same footage every year about it being destroyed. Ironically, a mockingjay in the right corner is what clued them in. It’s always there.
They also explain the details behind the uprisings in District 8. Katniss had only heard vague stories about them prior. They tell Katniss that discontent in the district had been growing since the previous Hunger Games and that her actions during the games inspired people to take action against the Capitol, instead of just talking about how much they hate their lives. The people of District 8 rehearsed their rebellion while Katniss visited District 8 during the Victor’s Tour. They began rebelling the day Katniss announced her engagement to Peeta, using the live broadcast as an excuse to be in public spaces.
Can you imagine hearing that your actions have caused a full-out rebellion against the government? One small choice, thousands dead. It sounds especially stressful if you consider the fact that the forest is supposed to be Katniss’s safe place. It is her escape from the stress of Panem and the games. Personally, I would be utterly overwhelmed. Putting myself in Katniss’s shoes always sounds like too much to me.
And it gets worse from there.
The women explain how the rebellion in District 8 ends. A flood of Peacekeepers enter District 8. The Capitol even bombs rebellion strongholds. People barely survived and, instead of this being a victory against the Capitol, it turned into a fight to stay alive at all. Instead of winning their freedom, most of District 8 is on lock down for two weeks. Even after the lockdown, the Capitol bombs their own factories where they believe the ideas of dissent emerged.
It’s hard to imagine a country that is completely willing to bomb its own people. Towards the beginning of this year, I watched a Netflix series about Waco. During the Waco siege, a government agency shot at and killed members of a cult. It is unsure who started firing first, the government or the people inside. Even that turned my stomach completely.
Panem takes that to a new extreme. They kill unarmed, innocent people just to discourage the idea of dissent. They bomb their own cities. They kill thousands. A government that doesn’t know the worth of human life isn’t a government worth having.
The fact that, in the case of the Capitol, they prioritize luxury goods and high standards of living over the lives of their citizens is especially disgusting. They would rather make sure a certain percentage of the population lives in luxury than make sure everyone is well-fed. No one is equal.
I completely agree with Katniss when she begins to muse about President Snow treating her like a fool. There is no way that a love story could actually solve the problem of uprising in the districts. Like I’ve said before, people aren’t upset that her and Peeta survived. Resentment had been building up for a long, long time.
However, I don’t think she fully understands the point of the wedding. While it will definitely help distract people in the Capitol, I don’t think that is it’s only purpose. It will also create a divide between her and the people in the districts. President Snow’s hope is that if he shows the nation how well she’s living in comparison to them, they’ll resent her too and maybe step away from the idea of rebelling.
Chapter Eleven Thoughts
When Katniss goes to leave the woods and return home, she finds that the fence has been electrified. She wonders if it was intentional. Did Thread, the new Head Peacekeeper of District 12, want an excuse to arrest her? Or is it just to make his rule of the district more strict? How will she get back inside? And how did they know she had left for the woods to begin with? The timing of when electricity was restored to the fence couldn’t be a complete coincidence.
I don’t know if I agree with her idea that there are cameras built into the districts, though. If there were, the Capitol would have found out about the possibility of an uprising in 8 long before they did. I also don’t think it would be worth the investment to stock a poor, underdeveloped district with a ton of cameras.
I do, however, think that there might be cameras locked onto Katniss at all times. Considering Panem’s technological feats, I wouldn’t be surprised if she were constantly tracked by hard to detect cameras. They could be as small as a speck of dust in the air. How else would President Snow have learned about Gale and her kissing, deep in the forest? Is anyone brave enough, or sneaky enough, to follow two well-trained hunters, completely undetected?
When Katniss arrives home, our suspicions are confirmed. Peacekeepers are waiting for her to arrive. They knew she had entered the woods. Someone must have been watching her. However, it’s not confirmed how. I still doubt the fact that a spy could be following Katniss 24/7 undetected. Cameras feel more likely.
Which makes me wonder about what would have happened had Katniss really tried to leave District 12. Would they have been detected instantly? Perhaps it’s a good thing Gale wasn’t into the idea of leaving. They all would have been punished as traitors to the nation, assuredly in some type of sadistic and cruel way.
Can you imagine how stressful it would be, though, waiting for Katniss to return? Peeta and Haymitch were also in the home when Katniss arrived. No one had any real idea of where Katniss went. She didn’t tell her mother. The dread of having to sit there and wait for hours must have been absolutely dreadful.
What’s also dreadful is what the Capitol considers appropriate television. It seems like their only forms of entertainment are propaganda clips for the Capitol and clips from previous Hunger Games. Any other type of television show seems nonexistent. Perhaps they want to avoid the creation of celebrities. If they share power with famous people, they’ll have less of a monopoly on power.
However, that may be stupid on their behalf. They make tributes the only type of celebrity there is, giving people who suffer in the districts and under the abuse of the Capitol the only other type of power people of Panem have: fame. Everyone knows and loves their victors. Is it a mistake to give power to people you’ve hurt? Obviously so. If they didn’t give victors so much power, they may have avoided the rebellion.